The Appraisal

  PRAISE FOR ANNA PORTER

  “Enchanting! With a fabulous blend of memory, myth, and mystery, of melancholy, comedy, and irony, Anna Porter conjures up moments of magic. The past comes alive in the only way it should, as suggestion rather than as truth.”

  — MODRIS EKSTEINS, author of Walking Since Daybreak on The Storyteller

  “This is a gutsy book, passionately written and brilliantly researched. It is a historical knock-out, a real tour-de-force.”

  — IRVING ABELLA, Shiff Professor of Canadian Jewish History at York and co-author of None Is Too Many on Kasztner’s Train

  “A tale of breathtaking chutzpa, the gravest personal risk, dark intrigue, human frailty and devastating clashes of personality.”

  — MICHAEL R. MARRUS, CHANCELLOR ROSE, and RAY WOLFE, Professor Emeritus of Holocaust Studies, University of Toronto on Kasztner’s Train

  “Kasztner’s Train is Schindler’s List-plus. Brilliant read. Brilliant history. Brilliant Porter.”

  — GEORGE JONAS

  “Crisply written, ingeniously plotted . . . an impressive debut.”

  — GLOBE AND MAIL on Hidden Agenda

  “Superior fiction. Crisp prose, inventive plot, convincing characters . . . A major new talent.”

  — SAN DIEGO UNION on Hidden Agenda

  “Lively . . . mysterious deaths and plenty of insider publishing stuff along the way.”

  — NEW YORK TIMES on Hidden Agenda

  “The Storyteller represents a much higher level of literary accomplishment, a worthy addition to the growing literature of displacement, and a poignant reminder that the best history is not always written by the winners.”

  — TORONTO STAR

  “Porter manages a difficult feat — she conveys the heartbreaking innocence of childhood with an overlay of the knowledge and humour of the person she is today.”

  — GLOBE AND MAIL on The Storyteller

  “The Storyteller shows that great storytellers are both born and made. Like grandfather, like granddaughter.”

  — CHATELAINE

  “This is a tightly plotted, well-written, and richly atmospheric novel.”

  — BOOKLIST on Mortal Sins

  ALSO BY ANNA PORTER

  FICTION

  The Bookfair Murders

  Mortal Sins

  Hidden Agenda

  NON-FICTION

  Buying a Better World: George Soros and Billionaire Philanthropy

  The Ghosts of Europe: Journeys through Central Europe’s Troubled Past and Uncertain Future

  Kasztner’s Train: The True Story of Rezso Kasztner, Unknown Hero of the Holocaust

  The Storyteller

  For Julian, the art-lover

  ***

  CONTENTS

  Chapter 1

  Chapter 2

  Chapter 3

  Chapter 4

  Chapter 5

  Chapter 6

  Chapter 7

  Chapter 8

  Chapter 9

  Chapter 10

  Chapter 11

  Chapter 12

  Chapter 13

  Chapter 14

  Chapter 15

  Chapter 16

  Chapter 17

  Chapter 18

  Chapter 19

  Chapter 20

  Chapter 21

  Chapter 22

  Chapter 23

  Chapter 24

  Chapter 25

  Chapter 26

  Chapter 27

  Chapter 28

  Chapter 29

  Chapter 30

  Chapter 31

  Chapter 32

  Chapter 33

  Chapter 34

  Chapter 35

  Chapter 36

  Sneak Peek: Hidden Agenda by Anna Porter

  About the Author

  Copyright

  CHAPTER 1

  He had been coming to the Gerbeaud for thirty years, but he never tired of it. During the summer he liked to sit under its wide, grey umbrellas on Vörösmarty Square, enjoying snippets of conversation at adjoining tables and watching life go by. It was a cozy respite from the nastiness of work. He didn’t much care whether the service was slow, the chrome tabletop wiped clean, or his espresso lukewarm, he loved the tangy black coffee oozing across his tongue and the reassuring normalcy of unfolding the daily paper on its wooden holder. He savoured the familiarity.

  Although pretty much everything in Hungary had changed since the advent of the “market economy,” the Gerbeaud’s sole concession to the winds of capitalism had been a steady increase in prices. The new owners had left the rest of it alone. He could still sit here as long as he wished, nursing the single espresso that cost him a quarter of a good day’s wages, and the waitresses never pushed him to reorder.

  There had been a time when the manager, sleek as a young trout in her fitted black dress, had refilled his delicate china cup and hadn’t charged for it, but she had long gone to greater fortunes in the States. Her name was Klari, now probably changed to Claire, or maybe Clara to preserve a touch of the Continent. She would have discovered by now that it cost a damned sight more than an occasional refill of coffee to buy a policeman in the so-called home of the free. Even in Budapest, bribery was no longer a bargain.

  At the table beside his, a young man wearing Gucci wraparound sunglasses, a gold Tissot watch, a collarless white shirt, and beige calf-leather pants was reading the Wall Street Journal. He was sucking on a split of champagne, surreptitiously checking his watch. Someone was keeping him waiting. He didn’t like it, but he wasn’t going to betray any anxiety. A man in Gucci wraparound glasses couldn’t admit to being kept waiting. He seemed familiar. A long-ago police lineup? Judging from his attire, his career had blossomed since then.

  It didn’t matter. The real target of Attila’s interest was near the first wide window, her back to the pastries counter and across from a frothy-haired man who also looked vaguely familiar. Her elbows were on the table and her long blond hair was dangling over an open blue file folder placed between them. Sheets of paper dropped so fast from her fingers, he presumed she was speed-reading until she came to the last sheet, which she stared at for several minutes. She closed the folder, pushed it toward her companion, and leaned forward as she talked. He listened, then produced something from his breast pocket. A picture? A passport? It was small, dark, and oblong. She palmed it so quickly that had Attila not been watching he would have missed the movement.

  He scanned the room, pretending to pay equal attention to all the customers. He was pleased that neither the woman nor her companion had once looked at him.

  The waitress, a country girl with short henna-red hair, was asking the Wall Street Journal man if she could take his spare chair. A group of German tourists was next in line for a table with not enough chairs. She asked in Hungarian, her hand on the chair, her meaning fairly clear, but he pretended not to understand. Playing for time, Attila thought, time to decide whether to reveal he had been waiting for someone. Without relinquishing her hold on the chair, the waitress — he must find out her name — asked, “Okay?” For emphasis, she jiggled the back of the chair, clattering its metal legs on the asphalt.

  The fellow nodded without enthusiasm, swivelling his head toward the group of tourists. One of them waved and shouted “Vielen Dank.” The Habsburg Empire had self-destructed some ninety years ago, but German speakers still viewed Budapest as an anachronistic piece of Austrian territory.

  At the table behind Attila’s, three elderly Hungarian women were debating the r
elative merits of the chestnut purée — sweet, traditional, brandy-basted — and the kugel loaf — historically more interesting, but less tasty. In the centre of the square, under the seated bronze statue of Mihály Vörösmarty, Hungary’s beloved poet, three young men in faded blue jeans were making a small drug deal. Vörösmarty was looking down as if observing the activities of the young men. The vendor pulled a plastic bag from his pocket and offered a taste. Hardly worth the effort, it was no more than ten ounces. “Be faithful to your land forever, oh Hungarian . . .” The great poet’s words ran around the pedestal, where a bronze phalanx of fellow Hungarians formed Vörösmarty’s adoring public. The buyer finger-tasted the coke and nodded to his companion, who would be carrying the cash. Street value of maybe a couple of thousand dollars. Small-time dealer. Attila assumed he worked the hotels on the Pest side and some of the classy apartments along the tramline. A couple of years ago Attila would have been bearing down on them. But back then they’d have already spotted him for a cop and moved the trade somewhere else. What was it about him that had changed so much in only two years?

  Attila had been hunched over his table, a broad-shouldered, greying man, balding on top, overweight, ham-fisted, thick-necked, his shirt collar and jacket both too tight. He straightened his back when the young dealer glanced at him, mildly suspicious, but then the dealer palmed the money and handed over the merchandise without a second look at Attila.

  The man with the Wall Street Journal examined his bill, counted some forints into the tray, and stood up to leave. His pants, caught in the wedge of his ass, stuck to his thighs. He must have gained weight since he bought them, Attila thought with some satisfaction. Anyway, it was too warm for leather pants.

  His attention was caught by a young woman, her red hair flying, her light-blue summer dress swinging, and her slender white heels flying over the paving stones as she ran toward the Gerbeaud. She lifted her long legs over the silk rope barrier, straddling it for a second, her cotton skirt billowing around her, offering a glimpse of her white cotton panties, then she was wrapping her arms around the sweaty young man with the calf skin caught between his buttocks. “Jancsi,” she called him, her voice soft as the inside of her thighs.

  “Where the hell have you been?” he demanded. Obviously, although the days of swooning over Westerners were long gone, he still thought it stylish to sound foreign.

  The woman by the window glanced at the gilt-framed mirror above her companion’s head. She adjusted her silk scarf, flicked her hair over her shoulder, then made that little moue that some women make when they are checking their makeup. She stood up with her weight on her palms flat against the table. Attila figured she was probably still exhausted from her flight and the long drive from Vienna, but she recovered quickly and walked out fast, her dress clinging to her legs, a leather handbag dangling from her arm. She was pretty, although a little older than pretty warranted, and her bare arms and long legs showed the kind of muscle earned by regular workouts. Her erstwhile companion stayed at the table, sipping coffee and digging into the large serving of chestnut purée that had sat there ignored for the past twenty minutes. He was no longer only vaguely familiar. The narrow forehead under the froth of hair. He ran a posh art shop on Váci Street. Attila had paid him a visit about ten years ago. The man had been caught with some stolen primitive art. Indian. He couldn’t remember what the outcome was, except that this man had somehow got away with it.

  Attila laid his change on the tray and followed her across the square, past Vörösmarty’s statue, the McCafé, the Hard Rock Café, the exorbitantly expensive clothing stores, down to the Danube, where his quarry was marching past the souvenir vendors with only an occasional glance at the river. Although she did pause for a moment to survey Gellért Hill in all its spring glory, she was not behaving like a tourist. A tourist would have stopped at the Shakespeare statue outside the Marriot Hotel and read the words on the brass plaque.

  He kept at a distance as she crossed to Buda over the Szabadság Bridge and walked around the periphery of a small square (why the hell was it under construction again?) to the Gellért Hotel.

  CHAPTER 2

  She had chosen the Gellért less for its old-world charm than for its several entrances. She preferred the small rooms at the back. They didn’t offer the view of the Danube for which the hotel was known, but they were adequate. A single bed, a narrow desk, a phone, two shelves, a hanger for clothes, and a safe. She preferred no fuss and not too much cleaning. Maids came only early in the morning for light cleaning and bed making. The view was of the side of Gellért Hill where, late at night, noise makers cavorted and played music and lovers had open-air sex.

  Helena had been here before but with different hair, a different name, and a man she had liked more than she wanted to. He had booked a suite at the front of the hotel, ordered flowers, and they had danced to lackadaisical gypsy music in the dining room. She didn’t like dancing to gypsy music, but that was not the reason they broke up. She had not been ready for a long-term relationship. She was struggling with too much unresolved anger and a couple of persistent ghosts. The ghosts still refused to go quietly, but she had almost managed to master her rage. But Robert was no longer waiting.

  She opened her black canvas holdall and arranged her clothes over the bedcover: black pants, a grey woollen sweater, black T-shirt, a black hoodie, faded black Nike running shoes, thin skin-coloured pantyhose, a short white cardigan, a small-brimmed foldable hat, five cell phones, black leather gloves, dark-rimmed glasses, a long pearl-grey linen jacket with a high collar, a raincoat, a cross-strapped navy bathing suit, four passports, a clear plastic bag containing a black wig with a fringe and a light-brown one, a small Revlon makeup case, a vial of face cream, the photograph Kis had given her, a foldable flashlight, wire cutters, a pocketbook, a Nikon Coolpix 16MP, a suede sheath containing a long-handled straight knife with a thin blade, a snub-nosed SwissMiniGun with six bullets.

  She put the wigs and passports into the safe.

  She slipped out of her dress, untied the blue silk scarf, placed the slingback shoes next to the door, and pulled on the black pants, the T-shirt, and the hoodie. She removed her blond wig and laid it, its tendrils trailing, on one pillow and pushed the second pillow lengthwise under the covers. From a short distance, it looked like a figure lying knees up, face to the wall.

  Her own hair was light brown with a few grey streaks, cut short and soft on the sides, bristly on top. She used a dollop of gel to make it lie flat. Standing in front of the mirror, she removed the blue eyeshadow and thick lashes and peeled off the thin plastic strip over her upper lip. She selected a dark purple lipstick from her collection of makeup pencils and dabbed it on her lips. Her reflection showed an almost middle-aged woman who didn’t much care about her appearance. She packed the flashlight, the handgun, the wire cutters, and the camera into her backpack and pulled on the pair of frayed running shoes.

  She picked up the slingbacks and left the room, dropping the shoes at the last moment as she pulled the door closed so they would be just inside the door. She hung the “Do Not Disturb” sign on the door handle.

  She took the back stairs next to the wrought-iron elevator that ferried guests down to the hotel’s famous Turkish baths. She showed her plastic key-card to the attendant, went through the baths’ exit between the two stone Grecian figures, and walked down toward the river.

  The tall heavy-set man she’d noticed in the Gerbeaud was standing at the tram stop, leaning against the ticket machine, frequently glancing into a paperback book while observing the Gellért’s main entrance. He looked at her for only a fraction of a second as she stepped over the tram tracks. She was sure he had not recognized her. He didn’t seem very committed to his task. Perhaps he was a retired policeman. She had seen dozens of them all over Prague, Bratislava, and Berlin, even in Warsaw, although not so many there. Most of the old Polish police and security men had long gone to villages where th
ey would be harder to identify. She had tracked one of them a few years ago. It had not been easy. He was now farming potatoes near Częstochowa. Back in the 1980s, he had been high up in the Ministry of Public Works. He had taken a ten-by-twelve-cm Leonardo da Vinci drawing as payment for keeping an informer out of jail. Her job had been to recover it.

  The Poles were less forgiving than the Czechs, Slovaks, and the Hungarians. In Budapest, beneficiaries of the Communist era didn’t need to hide. That made it easy to find people. Unless they were dead.

  Géza Márton had left here in 1956 after the failed Hungarian Revolution. Had he returned recently, he would know whom the system still protected and who could still do him harm. But then he wouldn’t need her services.

  She ran along the river, taking long strides, pumping her arms, and slowly settling into her usual energetic jog. Although the sun had almost set, it was light enough to see the street signs, and the air was warm. In Toronto, there had still been snow on the ground, it was getting dark at 7:30 p.m., and the few early birds perched in the desolate trees in the Mártons’ garden had seemed stunned. The house was on a low hill, with the garden sloping down to more trees and bushes in the valley below. Géza was proud of his Georgian red-brick house with its tall bay windows, its white pillars flanking the entrance, and delighted with his young white oaks, his sugar maples, his spectacularly green rhododendrons, and his long sloping lawn — still brownish in April — that ended at the ravine.

  He had been pleased to show off his paintings, the nine quasi-Impressionists, a couple of almost Picassos, a possible Max Ernst, and a Watteau. Over the wide wooden staircase to the second floor, there had been a Rubens drawing of a nude, a Cellini, a Degas, and there were more paintings in the study, although Géza had saved the best for the master bedroom: an early Van Gogh, which he may have bought from her father, Simon. At their initial meeting, he had insisted she see it.